Okay will try it and let you know what the ears say
Interesting test. - Waiting for the results.
To my ears the TL974IN doesn’t reduce noise rather it changes the sound character for the worse i.e clipping/duller. will have to compare again though.
One thing unexpected on the breadboard (with TL274IN) is I seem to be getting oscillatory sounds with some higher volume settings and depending on the frequency setting
I’m starting to wonder if perhaps the above is caused because of the specs of the electret I have on our breadboard which is a BCM9765P-44 and its interaction with the 15k resistor at freq pot stage.
If i replace the 15k resistor for a 100k I get much less of the oscillation noise but an additional a high frequency whine is introduced. 47k tames the oscillation somewhat + eliminates the wine but i think the response is less ideal than the 15k.
An observation: when I eliminate-jumper the 15k resistor, general noise disappears drastically( im referring to the general circuit noise discussed in the thread) but the frequency is fixed.
Otherwise I would say its a partial success although compared with the k8118 the breadboard attempt doesn’t sound as sensitive + oscillation depending on the volume/frequency combination.
So might this be my electrets bandwidth 20-16khz or impedance characteristics misbehaving with the 15 k?
In this case what would be better characteristics for the electret? Presumably the electret used on my K8118 is the 6mm M63 microcel of which I cant see a bandwidth spec?
Ok. It seems that changing the amplifier to low noise version doesn’t make a big difference…
yeah was fun to try swapamps
doing some further research the M63 seems to have a bandwidth of 20-16khz and has similar specs to the BCM9765P-44 despite differences in size
just wondering then, shouldn’t that range be higher say up to 30khz for bat calls? I had assumed that the M63 is used as i came across it hunting on the vellman site.
any idea of what might be making the bread-boarded version sound less sensitive, would the M63 help? although if its the same spec i cant see how
anyway we have still enjoyed building it so fa,r both the kit and the legwork required for bread-boarding
It seems that maybe the sensitivity of the M63 is slightly higher on high frequencies…
Anyhow, your breadboard version seems to work fine!
Yes it is working
Tested in the back garden last night side by side with the k8118 its not as adept at picking up calls though. But as you point out I will try to get an M63, maybe I can scare two bats with one electret, fixing the sensitivity issue as well as the oscillation at the same time.
There are some other elements which spec at 20khz bandwidth, might also be worth a try.
Indeed, maybe even better than M63…